Thursday, May 17, 2007

Capital Punishment, or "Legalised Murder"

Hey, seeing as I have nothing more apt to write about, I'm going to do my best to sincerely criticise one of the staunch policies utilised by two of my favourite countries, America and China. Also, before I forget, good job for polluting our atmosphere with all those greenhouse gases and ozone depleting substances guys, just great work.
Back on track, I want to talk about how moronic capital punishment really is. I admit, at face value, it seems like a considerable option. Someone kills another person, the punishment is them dying as well. 1+1=2. Well, okay, let's look at the specific arguments that pro-capital punishment lobbyists have come up with.
  1. Punishment

Fine, this seems fair. Death is a pretty nasty punishment. Or is it? Think about it, a few days or weeks of awful fear, and then...nothing. Because you're dead. Being dead isn't a punishment, or a reprieve, it's nothing. When you're dead, you don't feel anything. So it's not really a punishment at all. I admit, the death of the victim will deny them their future, and all associated pleasures, but the death of the criminal won't be denying him a great life, will it? The alternative (which I condone) is life imprisonment (parole is subjective). That, compared to a bit of fear and 50 years rotting in the ground, is a considerably greater degree of punishment.

2. Safety of the Public

Another feasible point, if you happen to live in the 1800's and don't have a justice system that is perfectly capable of keeping the public safe by locking the perpetrator up in prison for a long time. But I suppose just killing the guy costs a lot less, so hell, let's do that.

3. Retribution (revenge)

Let's not sugar the pill by calling it retribution, a major argument for the death penalty is revenge. That guy killed your brother/son/friend, so you should be able to kill him back. Well, if anyone has a better example of Christians picking out Bible passages to suit their feelings, let me know. Usually it's "turn the other cheek", or "thou shalt not kill", but whenever it suits them they break out the Old Testament "eye for an eye" shit. What happened to forgiveness? I know it isn't easy, but for God's sake if you advocate killing someone you're just as bad as he was.

4. Deterrence

Give me a break. Despite the fact that innumerable studies show that having a death penalty doesn't put people off killing each other, the alternative of life imprisonment isn't much of a better option. If someone has a gun in their hand and someone they want to kill on the other end, they aren't going to be weighing up the subtle differences between spending the rest of their life in a wooden box in the ground or a 10' x 6' box above the ground.

5. No possibility of Rehabilitation.

Listen, I've seen a man in prison who killed another man over 30 years ago, as a florid racist and homophobe. Now, after nearly half a century in prison, he want to be paroled so that he can further his interest in book binding. No one person is constant, and just because the circumstances they found themselves in that led to them killing someone occurred, it doesn't mean that it will happen again.

Look, murderers need to be punished. Hell yes, of course they do. I just think that there are better ways to punish them than to murder them. Honestly, in this "civilised" society, can we not find a way to teach our offenders the error of their actions and encourage them to change their ways? I know, it sounds like a sermon, but come on. There's something about death that makes me think that it shouldn't be induced by anyone, for any reason. No crime, no matter how awful, deserves death. Every single aim of capital punishment can be attained to further and more efficient extent by keeping the offender alive.

As for those countries which use the death penalty for non-fatality related crimes, such as drug-trafficking, homosexuality, or "political deviance", I have a message for them. If you're doing this in the name of a God, then here's some good luck from me. Because if there is a God, you're damn sure going to need luck when he judges your disgusting, pathetic, warped selves.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Good argument...the only problem is, if something like this happens to you God forbid, you'd want the person killed. It is easier to preach than to practice. People who kill maliciously, don't deserve to live...yes if there is ANY explaination to why they killed which could even remotely be justifiable, then perhaps an alternative would be acceptable. Cold blooded murder is inexcusable.

The Ante Poster said...

An understandable stance, but I return your attention to my argument about death being neither punishment nor repreive. After the intial emotional tirade of the acute event, I would prefer to see the perpetrator suffer a hefty sentence in jail (providing the environment was inducive to suffering), instead of being killed and suffering no more.

Anonymous said...

Good point. I agree with that. Like I don't think the hanging of Saddam Hussein was justice. When he died, he still thought he was a hero, so you didn't really punish him or make him suffer. I guess, had he been given life imprisonment, and then had to live in the real world, the harsh reality of it would have made him suffer more. Oh well...why is that all of us become very sadistic as exams near!?

Anonymous said...

not that i agree with this, but i suspect the financial implications of keeping these criminals alive is a big factor.

The Ante Poster said...

nb:my sarcastic point on killing them being easier. It's a hassle and a financial strain keeping people alive, maybe we should just ship them to Africa, which we ignore even more. They'll die of starvation there.

Anonymous said...

You should be running for MP mate!

Anonymous said...

tramadol online tramadol no prescription needed - tramadol hcl 50 mg withdrawal

Anonymous said...

true religion jeans, burberry outlet online, true religion jeans, timberland, michael kors, coach outlet, converse pas cher, hogan, true religion jeans, hollister, michael kors, vanessa bruno, nike free run uk, nike air max, ugg boots, ugg boots, michael kors outlet, tn pas cher, ray ban uk, vans pas cher, michael kors outlet, coach purses, air force, coach outlet, abercrombie and fitch, nike roshe, ralph lauren uk, michael kors outlet, kate spade handbags, oakley pas cher, north face, nike air max, mulberry, sac guess, true religion outlet, michael kors outlet, lacoste pas cher, nike air max, michael kors outlet, hermes, burberry, michael kors, nike blazer, new balance pas cher, michael kors, north face, lululemon, hollister pas cher, ray ban pas cher, replica handbags